An argument in favor of the elimination of affirmative action

And I want to add a small point that irks me a bit. AA seeks to ensure that African Americans or females would be preferred if they are equally qualified or have comparable skills.

However, some French schools do implement affirmative action in that they are obligated to take a certain number of students from impoverished families.

Neither do most football or basketball fans care whether their team reflects ethnic and gender diversity, but whether they are the best combination of players available. One of the main arguments Kahlenberg attributes to the lack of class-based affirmative action in higher education, or even the discussion of it, is the financial implications is has.

The proponent of equal opportunity would urges us to get beyond racial and gender criteria in assignment of offices and opportunities and treat each person, not as an average white or Black or female or male, but as a person judge on his or her own merits.

Opposing Views on Affirmative Action

Affirmative Action simply shifts injustice, setting Blacks, Hispanics, Native Americans, Asians and women against young white males, especially ethnic and poor white males. Or how about the Egyptians, demanding that Greece accept thousands of Egyptian students over Greeks, due to the work of Alexander the Great s of years previously?

Although both of these cases have upheld race-based affirmative action at UT Austin, it has brought race-based affirmative action into more scrutiny and has opened up the conversation for an alternative, class-based affirmative action.

August Tournament - United States should ban Affirmative Action

The policies were originally developed to correct decades of discrimination and to give disadvantaged minorities a boost. Getting our bearings straight. As Barbara Bergmann argues, "Diversity has positive value in many situations, but in some its value is crucial.

Pojman In this essay I set forth nine arguments against Strong Affirmative Action, which I define as preferential treatment, discriminating in favor of members of under-represented groups, which have been treated unjustly in the past, against innocent people.

The goal of AA is to ensure that employers and educators offer minorities an equal chance. This figure has in-creased significantly from A new study has shown that "even when candidates who are black hold degrees from elite schools such as Stanford, Duke, and, yes, Harvard.

Perpetuating Stigma and Racial Thinking? Retrieved May 3, http: The school had a policy of rating potential applicants on a point system. If we remove AA, white students will dominate colleges. Bollinger, which forced University Michigan Law School to use race-based decisions in admissions.

There were many real reasons affirmative action was put in place and there are even more for why it needs to stay a while longer.

A Third Perspective to Affirmative Action

But AA has helped improve the situation. To get a better feel for mismatch in practice, put yourself in the shoes of a freshman in an intro calculus class. My opponent, in comical discombobulation, makes my argument for me! Under-funding continues to this day leading to fewer resources like books and laboratories, larger class sizes, and less qualified teachers.

Affirmative action

If only considering directors with at least three directorships, This may equate to lowering minimum requirements for the National University Entrance Examination, which is a mandatory exam for all students to enter university.

The equal results argument or axiom misses a greater part of the picture. Some schools, in neighborhoods labeled "Priority Education Zones", are granted more funds than the others.Top Ten Reasons Affirmative Action Should be Eliminated Top 10 Reasons Affirmative Action Is a Bad Idea Affirmative action is the policy of giving preferential treatment to minorities, women, and other underrepresented groups.

The strongest argument in favor of requiring affirmative action that Boonin addresses is the "bias-elimination argument", according to which affirmative action is defined as a means by which to eliminate intentional and unintentional. Affirmative action is a set of public policies that were designed for the elimination of discrimination toward race, color, sex, etc.

An argument that the author presents for Affirmative Action is that of the 'merit principal', which states that people should be awarded for possesing the highest merit. - Affirmative Action - Public.

On balance, affirmative action in the United States is desirable

Con’s shamble of a case consists of four claims: (a) affirmative action costs the government and businesses billions of dollars, (b) affirmative action harms minorities, (c) affirmative action causes racial tension, and (d) affirmative action is sexist. Affirmative action, also known as reservation in India and Nepal, positive action in the UK, and employment equity (in a narrower context) in Canada and South Africa, is the policy of promoting the education and employment of members of groups that are known to have previously suffered from discrimination.

Historically and internationally, support for affirmative action has sought to achieve. Henttinger believes that affirmative action is not reverse discrimination because the definition of discrimination is the differentiation between two things on the basis of some principle of reason for instance I have a discriminating tastes when it comes to alchoall.

An argument in favor of the elimination of affirmative action
Rated 3/5 based on 91 review